Website builders like Wix, Squarespace and GoDaddy have made it possible for anyone to build a website in an afternoon. So why would a small business pay a web designer? Sometimes you shouldn't. Here's an honest comparison to help you decide.
What a website builder gets you
A builder gives you templates, a drag-and-drop editor and hosting for a monthly subscription. For a hobby, a one-page placeholder or a business that's just testing an idea, that can be all you need.
The catch is everything else. You choose the layout, write every word, source the photos, set up the domain and email, work out SEO settings and keep it all up to date. The subscription is cheap; your time isn't.
Where DIY websites usually fall short
- The words. Most DIY sites talk about the business, not the customer's problem. Clear, persuasive copy is what turns visitors into enquiries.
- Mobile layout. Templates that look great on a laptop often turn into long, awkward pages on a phone, where most of your visitors are.
- Speed. Heavy templates, apps and full-size photos slow pages down, and slow pages lose visitors and rankings.
- Local SEO. Page titles, headings, service pages, structured data and your Google Business Profile all need setting up properly to show up locally.
- Upkeep. Prices change, services change, photos date. DIY sites tend to be built once and then left.
What a web designer adds
A good web designer brings a plan, not just a layout: what each page is for, what visitors should do next, and how the site will be found. They write or polish the words, make it fast and mobile-first, set up the technical SEO, and, on a monthly plan, keep it updated so you don't have to.
The traditional downside was cost. A one-off build from a freelancer or agency can run into thousands up front, and then you still need hosting and someone to make changes. That's why I offer monthly website plans instead.
The cost comparison
A builder subscription plus a domain, a premium template and a few apps adds up to a monthly bill anyway, before you count your own hours. My Basic Website is R499/month and my Professional Website is R999/month, with design, writing, hosting, SSL, your domain, updates and support all included, and no setup fee. For many small businesses, that's not far off the cost of doing it yourself, without the evenings spent wrestling with an editor.
When a website builder is the right choice
- You enjoy design and writing, and have the time to keep the site current.
- You're testing an idea and just need a page to point people to.
- You don't rely on Google or your website for new customers.
When a web designer is the better choice
- Your website needs to bring in enquiries or sales, not just exist.
- You want to show up when locals search for what you do.
- You'd rather spend your time running your business.
- You already have a DIY site that isn't working. A website redesign can move it across without starting your online presence from scratch.
Not sure which way to go? Send me your current site or your idea and I'll tell you honestly whether you need a designer, or whether a builder will do.
